James T. Lahey's is an independent insurance agency located in Potsdam, NY. We are dedicated to you and your home, auto and small business insurance needs. You are a person, not a policy.

Home, Auto & Small Business Insurance

Fill out this form to get a quote.

Home Insurance

Auto Insurance

Business Insurance

We offer home, automobile, and small business insurance products from the following insurance carriers: Main Street America Group, Allstate, NYCM Insurance, Nationwide, Otsego Mutual, Travelers, CNA Surety, New York Municipal Insurance Reciprocal (NYMIR) and Erie & Niagara Insurance Association. Having multiple insurance carriers under one agency allows us to offer competitive prices on a variety of insurance products.

Hours & Location

28 Market Street

Potsdam, NY 13676

Tel: (315) 265-5640

Fax: (315) 265-5641

Monday - Friday

8 AM - 4:30 PM

Trusted Choice® agencies are dedicated to you and are committed to treating you as a person, not a policy. All Trusted Choice® agencies agree to adhere to a Pledge of Performance, designed to assure quality service that enables them to offer you competitive pricing, a broad choice of products and valuable advocacy.

As an independent insurance agency we offer multiple insurance carriers for home, auto, and small business all under one roof so you get competitive prices and bundles on a variety of insurance products.


Contact us directly to file your claim, or submit claims through your carrier. 

 Contact Us


28 Market Street
Potsdam, NY 13676

For any Questions or policy help, please call or email us:

(315) 265-5640  

Please note, policy changes cannot be made via email/website contact. 

28 Market Street, Potsdam, NY 13676
tel: (315) 265-5640   |   fax: (315) 265-5641

  • Facebook - Black Circle